You're stuck in traffic en route to that
soccer practice, the radio blaring, cell
phone ringing. You've had it. You're tired
of the frantic pace of your life. You need
to simplify. Live a more grounded,
elemental way of life.
Five thousand families had similar
thoughts. They wanted to be part of a PBS
reality show where three families are
chosen to re-create the life of
homesteaders in Montana in 1883. No SUVs.
No phones. No 9-to-5 grind. Just
the quiet rural life in one of the most
beautiful places on earth. A place where you
can't count the stars because there are
too many of them. A place to work the
earth and eat what you've grown with your
own hands and honest labor. Wood
stoves and cotton pants.
The only intrusion of modernity would be
the cameras and the availability of
modern medical care. The result is six
hours of riveting television that PBS calls
"Frontier House."
Maybe they should have called it "Be
Careful What You Wish For."
If you stop and think what you'd miss
about 2002 if you were back in 1883, a few
obvious things come to mindtoilet
paper and indoor plumbing being at the top
of the list. You'd also be glad to know
that, for safety reasons, the show's
producers won't let you undergo an 1883
root canal without novocaine. You also
won't be giving birth in 1883 when almost
one in every 100 deliveries ended with
the death of the mother. And when one in
every 10 children failed to live beyond
the first year of life.
But after watching the families struggle
on "Frontier House," you learn what
really made life difficult in 1883the
amount of time and effort it took to stay
alive in a rural setting of near self-sufficiency.
It's hard work swinging an ax to chop the
wood that keeps you warm, that heats
your stove, that lets you cook. It's hard
work swinging a long-handled scythe to
bring in the hay for your milk cow and
your horses. It's hard work lugging water in
a barrel up from the river. Washing
clothes requires all the major muscle groups
in the back and arms. You sleep long hours
because you have to. You're
exhausted.
After watching the people on "Frontier
House" living the simple life, you may feel
a new affection for your furnace and your
refrigerator.
There's not much time for nature walks in
1883 Montana. Today, we tend to
romanticize nature. Nature in 1883 turns
out to be an enemy as often as it is an
ally. Mercifully for the participating
families, the show ends before the arrival of
winter. Still, they get a taste of one of
the great boot camps of lifethe 19th
century.
A good chunk of the rest of the world
still lives that way. But for those who live in
America, "Frontier House" makes us count
our blessings.
How did we get here from there? How did we
come to a world where even the
poorest Americans have a quality of life
the people of 1880 would not have
dreamed of?
At the heart of any explanation must be
what Adam Smith called the "propensity
in human nature to truck, barter and
exchange one thing for another." Free
markets. Capitalism. The grubby world of
profit and losswhat used to be called
commerce and we call business.
It is that world that created the
appliances that make life easy. It is that world
that helped create the wealth that lets so
many of us afford those gadgets.
Many forces created that wealth and spread
it widelygovernment regulation,
our legal system, our nonprofit sector and
tax policy all played a role. But the
engine that makes it all possible is business.
Much of our culture sneers at business.
Business is full of greedy, grasping
philistines. We are told of the great
power of corporations and the wealth of their
executives. Under capitalism, the rich get
richer and the poor get poorer.
People said the same thing back in the
1880s when they spoke of the corporate
giants of their daythe robber barons.
They lived like kings. The masses who
lived on the farm or who crowded into the
cities were desperately poor. The
critics concluded that capitalism is cruel
it leads to a world where a handful of
rich folks feast at the table; the masses
survive on the crumbs. They could not
foresee the rest of the storythe world
of today where the average American,
and even many of the poorest Americans
live better than the robber barons of the
19th century.
Hardship in 1880 was surviving the winter.
Today it's surviving without
high-speed Internet access. Material
well-being is no longer limited to the few.
Capitalism is the source of that transformation.
There's still vast inequality in America
today. Bill Gates has a much bigger
house than I do. And many Americans
struggle economically. But "Frontier
House" puts those struggles into
perspective. A snapshot of economic
well-being doesn't tell much of the story.
The real story unfolds over time.
The rich do get richer under capitalism.
But so do the rest of us.